Toxic effects of trace phenol/guanidine isothiocyanate (P/GI) on cells cultured nearby in covered 96-well plates
BMC Biotechnology volume 22, Article number: 35 (2022)
A mixture of phenol and guanidine isothiocyanate (“P/GI”, the principal components of TRIzol™ and similar products) is routinely used to isolate RNA, DNA, and proteins from a single specimen. In time-course experiments of cells grown in tissue culture, replicate wells are often harvested sequentially and compared, with the assumption that in-well lysis and complete aspiration of P/GI has no effect on continuing cultures in nearby wells.
To test this assumption, we investigated morphology and function of RAW 264.7 cells (an immortalized mouse macrophage cell line) cultured in covered 96-well plates for 4, 8, or 24 h at varying distances from a single control well or a well into which P/GI had been deposited and immediately aspirated completely.
Time- and distance-dependent disruptions resulting from proximity to a single well containing trace residual P/GI were seen in cell morphology (blebbing, cytoplasmic disruption, and accumulation of intracellular vesicles), cell function (pH of culture medium), and expression of genes related to inflammation (Tnfα) and autophagy (Lc3b). There was no transcriptional change in the anti-apoptotic gene Mcl1, nor the pro-apoptotic gene Hrk, nor in P/GI-unexposed control cultures. LPS-stimulated cells incubated near P/GI had lower expression of the cytokine Il6. These effects were seen as early as 4 h of exposure and at a distance of up to 3 well units from the P/GI-exposed well.
Exposure to trace residual quantities of P/GI in covered tissue culture plates leads to substantial disruption of cell morphology and function in as little as 4 h, possibly through induction of autophagy but not apoptosis. This phenomenon should be considered when planning time-course experiments in multi-well covered tissue culture plates.
96-well culture plates are often used to study cellular responses to various stimuli in vitro. To efficiently recover RNA, DNA, and protein from such specimens, a monophasic solution of phenol and guanidine isothiocyanate (“P/GI”, commercially available as TRIzol™, TRI Reagent™, and others) is often used . In controlled time-course experiments in multi-well tissue culture plates, replicate cultures can be treated with a stimulus at one time and harvested at various times afterwards using P/GI. Phenolic compounds  and guanidine compounds  are cytotoxic, but the incidental effects of trace amounts of these volatile substances, either separately or in combination, on adjacent cell culture wells (as opposed to direct exposure in culture medium) has not been investigated.
As a chaotrope, P/GI quickly breaks down cellular structures and dissolves cell components when added directly onto the culture dish. It may also induce programmed cell death (apoptosis [3, 4] or autosis ) or non-programmed cell death (necrosis ). Apoptosis, characterized by cell shrinkage, membrane blebbing, DNA condensation, and fragmentation, is triggered by activation of death receptor-induced extrinsic or cell injury-induced intrinsic pathways . Apoptotic pathway activation may be monitored by evaluating the expression of tumor necrosis factor α (Tnfα, a death receptor ), induced myeloid cell leukemia cell differentiation protein (Mcl1, a pro-survival protein at the intersection of the intrinsic and extrinsic apoptotic pathways ), and harakiri (Hrk, an intrinsic pro-death protein ). Autosis is an autophagy-dependent process initiated upon cellular stress and is characterized by plasma membrane blebbing and loss of cytoplasmic organelles in the absence of chromatin condensation . A progressive accumulation of autophagy-inducing peptides causes the degradation of pro-survival proteins leading to autosis . Changes in the expression of microtubule-associated proteins 1A/1B light chain 3B (Lc3b, a key factor in the initiation and maintenance of autophagy), can be an indicator of increased or inhibited autophagic flux . Necrosis is stimulated by cell injury or toxins and leads to cell edema, plasma membrane rupture, loss of cell organelles, and, ultimately, cell death . If no clear pattern of programmed cell death gene expression is detected alongside these morphological changes, necrosis is left as the presumptive cell death mechanism at work.
In the present study, we assessed whether exposure to residual trace amounts of P/GI (i.e. after complete aspiration of P/GI from a single well) affects ongoing cultures in nearby wells in covered 96-well tissue culture plates. We assessed cellular morphology and function, and expression of genes related to inflammation, autophagy, and cell death in RAW 264.7 cells (an immortalized murine macrophage cell line) plated at various distances from a well containing trace residual P/GI for short (4 h)- and long-term (8 h and 24 h) exposures, and in cells stimulated with bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS).
Results from experiments using two plate layouts (Fig. 1A1, A2), each conducted three times, demonstrate clear differences between cells incubated at various distances (in units of well diameter, termed “W1,” “W2,” W3,” and so on, see Fig. 1 legend) from a well into which P/GI was deposited and then immediately aspirated, and control cells incubated on separate 96-well plates without P/GI residue (“unexposed controls”). Because there were no significant differences between unexposed controls and cells in wells more than 3 wells away from P/GI, we have reported data only from W1-W3.
Effect of trace P/GI on culture medium pH
Phenol red was added to culture medium as a pH indicator. Phenol red is red–orange at physiologic pH (7.2–7.4), and deviations below 6.8 or above 8.2 appear yellow or fuchsia, respectively . To assess the effect of trace residual P/GI on medium pH, we used photography and spectroscopy to measure the ratio of absorbance at 560 nm (where higher values indicate a redder color, consistent with higher pH) and 430 nm (a reference wavelength). By 24 h after exposure to trace residual P/GI, the medium in W1 had higher 560/430 ratios than unexposed controls (Fig. 1B1, B2), suggesting a less active metabolic state (i.e. diminished production and secretion of acids into conditioned medium). No differences were seen at 8 h (Additional File 1: Fig. S1), or in wells at a greater distance than W1 from the P/GI-treated well.
Effect of P/GI on cell morphology
We examined whether exposure to trace residual P/GI affects cell morphology by light microscopy. Cells incubated at any distance from P/GI for 4 h were morphologically indistinguishable from time-matched unexposed controls, but by 8 h cells in W1 had various membrane abnormalities, including blebbing and multiple intracellular vesicles (see Additional File 1: Fig. S2). After 24 h, unexposed controls (Fig. 2A) had become near-confluent and displayed diverse morphologies typical of undifferentiated monocytes and M2-polarized macrophages . In contrast, many cells in W1 (Fig. 2B) had a strikingly shrunken appearance and extensive plasma membrane perturbations. Cells in W2 (Fig. 2C) possessed more intracellular vesicles than unexposed controls or cells in W3 (Fig. 2D) or W1, in which the cytoplasm was often too contracted to identify intracellular features.
The effect of P/GI on cellular pathways: programmed cell death, autophagy, and inflammation
The above results (diminished acid production and abnormal morphology) suggest that exposure to trace residual P/GI disrupts normal cell function. To explore whether this disruption might be mediated by changes in apoptotic pathways, the expression of 2 genes was interrogated. Mcl1 is an anti-apoptotic gene capable of regulating both intrinsic and extrinsic apoptotic pathways . Hrk is a pro-apoptotic member of the BH3-only family; when expressed it antagonizes MCL1, thereby allowing apoptosis to occur . Expression of both MCL1  and HRK  are under transcriptional control. Real-time polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) results for Mcl1 showed uniform expression at all distances from P/GI, equivalent to Mcl1 expression in unexposed controls, at all time points tested (24 h data shown in Fig. 3A; see Additional File 1: Fig. S3 for 4 h and 8 h data). Hrk was not detected in experimental samples regardless of duration of and distance from P/GI exposure.
We next queried the process of autophagy as a mediator of P/GI’s effects on morphology and acidity of culture medium. Experiments designed specifically to monitor autophagic flux generally capture protein abundance, modifications, and localization , but for our purposes—to determine whether autophagy might be impacted in cells near P/GI—mRNA data is sufficient. Transcription of Lc3b, an important protein in autophagosome membrane elongation, can be affected hours after cells are exposed to stimuli that produce changes in autophagy . No changes in Lc3b were detected at the 4 h time point (see Additional File 1: Fig. S3), but at both 8 h (Fig. 3B1) and 24 h (Fig. 3B2) there are lower levels of Lc3b in W1 compared to unexposed controls.
We also assayed expression of Tnfα, a gene associated with various processes, including programmed cell death and inflammation . Tnfα expression was significantly decreased in W1 at 4 h (Fig. 3C1), but by 24 h (Fig. 3C2) cells from W1—W3 had significantly elevated Tnfα transcripts.
Cells exposed to P/GI have disrupted responses to LPS stimulation
By running parallel experiments in cells stimulated with LPS, we were able to evaluate functional changes resulting from a proinflammatory stimulus in cells at various distances from P/GI. Compared to cells not treated with LPS, cells treated with LPS for 24 h but unexposed to P/GI (Fig. 4A1) were larger, flatter, and had well-defined intracellular vesicles—hallmarks of classic M1 polarization . LPS-stimulated cells cultured near P/GI residue displayed aberrant morphology (including shrunken cytoplasm, blebbing, and intracellular vesicles) at 4 h and 8 h (Additional File 1: Fig. S4), and by 24 h the cells in W1 (Fig. 4A2) had contracted cytoplasm and abundant blebbing. This phenotype was observed occasionally in W2 (Fig. 4A3) and W3 (Fig. 4A4); however, frequently these changes were obscured by the abundance of intracellular vesicles.
To assess the impact of P/GI on responses to an inflammatory stimulus, we measured interleukin 6 mRNA (Il6), a commonly used marker of the inflammatory response to LPS . Il6 is transcribed at high levels in LPS-stimulated macrophages, which we confirmed in P/GI-unexposed controls. P/GI produced a time- and distance-dependent diminishment of Il6 expression with LPS stimulation. After 4 h stimulation with LPS on culture plates containing residual trace P/GI, cells in W1 had lower Il6 (Fig. 4B1). At 8 h and 24 h suppression of Il6 transcription was more pronounced in W1 and became apparent in W2 and W3 as well (Fig. 4B2, B3). Expression patterns of other genes (Tnfα, Lc3b, and Mcl1) was not altered by LPS (see Additional File 1: Fig. S5).
Culture medium spectroscopy results (i.e. higher pH) suggest a less active metabolic state induced by proximity to trace residual P/GI, as metabolically active cells secrete acids continually into the medium . This is supported by diminished expression of Lc3b (indicating departure from physiologic autophagy ) and Tnfα (which plays a role in programmed cell death, bioenergetics, and initiating and sustaining inflammation in macrophages responding to damaged cells or pathogens [7, 15]). The delayed increase observed in Tnfα expression 24 h after exposure to P/GI may reflect a compensatory response to the initial insult. These disruptions in cell function are correlated with diminished responsiveness to LPS stimulation and induction of marked abnormalities in cell morphology .
A lack of modulation of Mcl1 and Hrk suggests that their associated programmed cell death pathways (apoptosis and autosis among them [9, 16]) may not be responsible for these apparent changes. Nevertheless, lack of transcriptional changes does not rule out the possibility that post-translational mechanisms mediate these processes.
Overall, these results suggest that even minute quantities of P/GI meaningfully disrupt normal cell function in a process potentially mediated by altered autophagy.
While the data demonstrate that trace P/GI is capable of affecting nearby macrophage morphology and function, the mechanisms behind these effects are unclear. This might be addressed by increasing the number of genes interrogated, adding protein data, and exploring P/GI’s effects on a second cell line, which were not done in this limited study. Additionally, we are unable to extrapolate how far-ranging these effects may be when multiple wells per plate contain trace residual P/GI (as expected in an experiment with multiple replicates per plate), because it would be difficult to characterize a well’s distance from the points of P/GI application.
Trace amounts of P/GI remaining in wells from which it has been immediately and fully aspirated are capable of disrupting cell morphology and function (including autophagy and inflammation) in macrophages cultured nearby on the same covered multi-well plate in a time- and distance-dependent fashion. Changes become apparent as early as 4 h after exposure, but it is likely that the molecular processes underlying these phenomena begin even earlier. In our experiments, no changes were observed in ongoing cultures distanced more than 3 wells away from a single well containing P/GI residue. However, it is possible that such changes occur in select processes even at large distances. Given the volatile nature of P/GI , fumes from trace P/GI left over after lysing cells at 1 collection point may affect other cells on the same culture plate at a later collection point. To avoid the confounding effects of even minute quantities of P/GI, laboratories should take these observations into account when designing time-course experiments in tissue culture plates.
RAW 264.7 cells (ATCC, Manassas, VA) were cultured in Dulbecco’s modified eagle medium (Gibco, Waltham, MA) + 10% fetal bovine serum (Gibco) in all experiments. Cells were seeded 105 per well in 200 μL medium in 96-well plates, covered, and cultured overnight at 37 °C in a humidified atmosphere with 5% CO2. After overnight culture, the medium was replaced, and for each of three time points (4, 8, or 24 h), plates were exposed to either residual P/GI or control (an empty well). The “exposure” entailed filling a single well with 100 μL TRI Reagent™ (Molecular Research Center, Cincinnati, OH), pipetting up and down, and immediately completely aspirating the solution. In some experiments, cells were treated concurrently with 0.2 ng/mL LPS to assess P/GI’s effect on the induction of inflammatory genes.
Cell morphology (using plate layout 1, Fig. 1A1) was observed under a light microscope (Zeiss, Jena, Germany) at 400X magnification at the end of each incubation period.
Cell culture medium color changes
Changes in the pH of the cell culture medium (plate layout 2, Fig. 1A2) were indirectly measured using color changes of phenol red (an acid–base indicator) in the culture medium. Briefly, 50 µL of the cell culture medium was sampled in duplicate from each well 30 min before the end of the incubation period, and absorbance was measured at 560 nm (with greater absorbance indicative of a higher pH) and 430 nm (a reference wavelength) using a SpectraMax M2e (Molecular Devices, San Jose, CA) . Results from both W1 wells in each experiment (Fig. 1B1) were averaged for data analysis (Fig. 1B2).
Gene expression analysis
After incubation, medium was aspirated, and cells were directly lysed in TRI Reagent™. RNA was extracted according to the manufacturer’s instructions and quantified using a NanoDrop 2000 (ThermoFisher, Waltham, MA). cDNA was synthesized using qScript cDNA SuperMix (Quantabio, Beverly, MA), with 100 ng RNA per reaction. RT-PCR was performed using TaqMan Gene Expression MasterMix (ThermoFisher) on the StepOne Plus (Applied Biosystems, Waltham, MA) with the following pre-validated primer/probe assay mixes: 18 s rRNA (Hs03003631_m1), Il6 (Mm00446190_m1), Tnfα (Mm00443258_m1), Lc3b (Mm00782868_sH), Mcl1 (Mm01257531_g1), and Hrk (Mm01208086_m1), all from ThermoFisher. Gene expression was quantified using the ddCt method for RT-PCR, in which genes of interest are normalized against a housekeeping gene (18S).
The culture medium 560/430 ratios and log-transformed gene expression measurements (Il6, Lc3b, Mcl1, Tnfα, normalized against 18S) of cells cultured at various distances (W1, W2, W3) from PG/I for 4 h, 8 h, or 24 h were compared to time-matched unexposed controls using the non-parametric Dwass-Steel-Critchlow-Fligner (DSCF) test for multiple pairwise comparisons. P-values less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant. All statistical analyses were performed using SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA) or Excel 2016 (Microsoft, Redmond, WA, USA).
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files.
Harakiri or DP5
Microtubule-associated proteins 1A/1B light chain 3B, aka MAP1LC3B or ATG8
Induced myeloid cell leukemia cell differentiation protein or BCL2L3
Phenol and guanidine isothiocyanate
Tumor necrosis factor α
Rio DC, Ares M, Hannon GJ, Nilsen TW. Purification of RNA using TRIzol (TRI Reagent). Cold Spring Harb Protoc. 2010;2010:pdb.prot5439-pdb.prot 5439.
Tolosa L, Martínez-Sena T, Schimming JP, Moro E, Escher SE, ter Braak B, et al. The in vitro assessment of the toxicity of volatile, oxidisable, redox-cycling compounds: phenols as an example. Arch Toxicol. 2021;95:2109–21.
Jung H-N, Zerin T, Podder B, Song H-Y, Kim Y-S. Cytotoxicity and gene expression profiling of polyhexamethylene guanidine hydrochloride in human alveolar A549 cells. Toxicol In Vitro. 2014;28:684–92.
Chen H-M, Lee Y-H, Wang Y-J. ROS-triggered signaling pathways involved in the cytotoxicity and tumor promotion effects of pentachlorophenol and tetrachlorohydroquinone. Chem Res Toxicol. 2015;28:339–50.
Maiuri MC, Zalckvar E, Kimchi A, Kroemer G. Self-eating and self-killing: crosstalk between autophagy and apoptosis. Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol. 2007;8:741–52.
Kaczmarek A, Vandenabeele P, Krysko DV. Necroptosis: the release of damage-associated molecular patterns and its physiological relevance. Immunity. 2013;38:209–23.
Parameswaran N, Patial S. Tumor necrosis factor-α signaling in macrophages. Crit Rev Eukaryot Gene Expr. 2010;20:87–103.
Huang K, O’Neill KL, Li J, Zhou W, Han N, Pang X, et al. BH3-only proteins target BCL-xL/MCL-1, not BAX/BAK, to initiate apoptosis. Cell Res. 2019;29:942–52.
Germain M, Slack RS. MCL-1 regulates the balance between autophagy and apoptosis. Autophagy. 2011;7:549–51.
Zahid MDK, Rogowski M, Ponce C, Choudhury M, Moustaid-Moussa N, Rahman SM. CCAAT/enhancer-binding protein beta (C/EBPβ) knockdown reduces inflammation, ER stress, and apoptosis, and promotes autophagy in oxLDL-treated RAW264.7 macrophage cells. Mol Cell Biochem. 2020;463(1–2):211–23. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11010-019-03642-4.
Michl J, Park KC, Swietach P. Evidence-based guidelines for controlling pH in mammalian live-cell culture systems. Commun Biol. 2019;2:144.
Shapouri-Moghaddam A, Mohammadian S, Vazini H, Taghadosi M, Esmaeili S, Mardani F, et al. Macrophage plasticity, polarization, and function in health and disease. J Cell Physiol. 2018;233:6425–40.
Senichkin VV, Streletskaia AY, Gorbunova AS, Zhivotovsky B, Kopeina GS. Saga of Mcl-1: regulation from transcription to degradation. Cell Death Differ. 2020;27:405–19.
Girnius N, Davis RJ. JNK promotes epithelial cell anoikis by transcriptional and post-translational regulation of BH3-only proteins. Cell Rep. 2017;21:1910–21.
Pearce EL, Pearce EJ. Metabolic pathways in immune cell activation and quiescence. Immunity. 2013;38:633–43.
Pihán P, Carreras-Sureda A, Hetz C. BCL-2 family: integrating stress responses at the ER to control cell demise. Cell Death Differ. 2017;24:1478–87.
This work was supported by NICHD R01 Grant [R01HD096209].
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Consent for publication
The authors declare they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Snedden, M., Singh, L., Kyathanahalli, C. et al. Toxic effects of trace phenol/guanidine isothiocyanate (P/GI) on cells cultured nearby in covered 96-well plates. BMC Biotechnol 22, 35 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12896-022-00766-2