Skip to main content

Table 2 Concentrations of toxic recombinant protein in process fluids due to expression in A. tumefaciens and N. benthamiana along with the corresponding hazardous process volumes

From: Risk assessment and bioburden evaluation of Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated transient protein expression in plants using the CaMV35S promoter

Process step (–)

Bacteria OD600nm (–)

Cbacteria (g DM L−1)b

Ctoxin from bacteria (µg L−1)b,c

Ctoxin from plant (µg L−1)b,c

Ctotal toxin [µg L−1]c

Vcritical (L) depending on LD50 of…

500 µg kg−1

1 µg kg−1

1 ng kg−1

Vprocess (L)

Cloning (E. coli)

2.00

0.79

62.13

0

62.13

650

1.30

0.001

0.002

Pre-culture (A. tumefaciens)

5.00

2.05

8.07

0

8.07

5.00 × 103

10.00

0.01

0.05

Fermentation

10.00

4.09

16.14

0

16.14

2.50 × 103

5.00

0.005

75

Infiltrated leavesd

0.50

0.21

0.81

0

0.81

50.00 × 103

100.00

0.10

1500

Extractiona

28.20 × 10−3/0

11.5 × 10−3/0

0.45 × 10−6/0

10.10 × 103

10.13 × 103

3.98

7.97 × 10−3

7.97 × 10−6

800

Bag filtrationa

12.30 × 10−3/0

0.50 × 10−6/0

0.19 × 10−6/0

9.62 × 103

9.62 × 103

4.19

8.39 × 10−3

8.39 × 10−6

640

Depth filtrationa

1.86 × 10−6/0

76.1 × 10−6/0

3.00 × 10−6/0

8.66 × 103

8.66 × 103

4.66

9.32 × 10−3

9.32 × 10−6

640

Sterile filtration

0

0

0

8.66 × 103

8.66 × 103

4.66

9,32 × 10−3

9.32 × 10−6

640

UF/DFe

0

0

0

0.17 × 106

0.17 × 106

0.23

46.6 × 10−3

0.47 × 10−6

32

  1. aIn these steps, the toxic recombinant protein is present due to (unintended) expression in bacteria and deliberate expression in plants
  2. bValues correspond to a process without/with blanching, if both values are identical only a single value is listed for brevity
  3. cPer liter of process volume
  4. dCalculated for freshly infiltrated plant material
  5. eThe depth filtrate was concentrated 20-fold by UF/DF. DM, dry mass; LD50, median lethal dose; n.a., not applicable; UF/DF, ultrafiltration/diafiltration