Comparative transfection of DNA into primary and transformed mammalian cells from different lineages
© Maurisse et al. 2010
Received: 18 June 2009
Accepted: 8 February 2010
Published: 8 February 2010
Skip to main content
© Maurisse et al. 2010
Received: 18 June 2009
Accepted: 8 February 2010
Published: 8 February 2010
The delivery of DNA into human cells has been the basis of advances in the understanding of gene function and the development of genetic therapies. Numerous chemical and physical approaches have been used to deliver the DNA, but their efficacy has been variable and is highly dependent on the cell type to be transfected.
Studies were undertaken to evaluate and compare the transfection efficacy of several chemical reagents to that of the electroporation/nucleofection system using both adherent cells (primary and transformed airway epithelial cells and primary fibroblasts as well as embryonic stem cells) and cells in suspension (primary hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells and lymphoblasts). With the exception of HEK 293 cell transfection, nucleofection proved to be less toxic and more efficient at effectively delivering DNA into the cells as determined by cell proliferation and GFP expression, respectively. Lipofectamine and nucleofection of HEK 293 were essentially equivalent in terms of toxicity and efficiency. Transient transfection efficiency in all the cell systems ranged from 40%-90%, with minimal toxicity and no apparent species specificity. Differences in efficiency and toxicity were cell type/system specific.
In general, the Amaxa electroporation/nucleofection system appears superior to other chemical systems. However, there are cell-type and species specific differences that need to be evaluated empirically to optimize the conditions for transfection efficiency and cell survival.
Numerous chemical and physical methods have been used to introduce DNA expression vectors into mammalian cells both in vitro and in vivo, including, but not limited to, calcium phosphate precipitation, microinjection, electroporation, receptor-mediated gene transfer, particle guns, viral vectors, polyfection and lipofection .
The use of cationic liposome/DNA complexes (lipoplexes) and cationic polymers/DNA (polyplexes) for the transfer of genes into somatic cells has become very popular due to its limited toxicity and relative effectiveness in vitro. The ionic interaction between cationic lipids and DNA leads to the formation of lipoplexes that are generally slightly cationic. The resulting DNA/lipid complexes fuse with the anionic cytoplasmic membrane and/or are introduced into the cells via an endocytic pathway . The delivery of the DNA into the nucleus is still not fully understood. While transfection with cationic lipids and polymers offers some advantages over viral transduction, such as simplicity of production, low toxicity, and low immunogenicity; it has yet to reach the levels observed with viral transduction. Furthermore, the adherence of the cationic complexes to the nucleic acid can interfere with its accessibility to enzymes required for processing the DNA .
One of the most effective and accessible physical transfection methods, electroporation (also known as electrotransfer, electropermeabilization, or nucleofection), involves the application of brief electric pulses to cells or tissues to increase the permeability of cells to macromolecules [1, 4]. The recent development of the nucleofection system has been a significant advance over standard electroporation systems that have been limited by high toxicity and a requirement for large numbers of cells. A number of cell lines have already been tested for their compatibility with the nucleofection system [5–12]. However, there have been no systematic studies comparing nucleofection to chemical transfection systems in various cell types across species.
In this study, chemical reagent-mediated transfection was compared to nucleofection using a number of primary and immortalized cell systems in three different mammalian species (human, rabbit, and pig) to evaluate the efficiency and toxicity. The results presented here indicate that nucleofection is more effective than chemical transfection reagents from several different cationic categories (dendrimer, polyethylenimine, lipid) at delivering DNA into a variety of different cell types. These studies also provided useful insight into transfection optimization conditions and relative cell viability for the various cells tested.
Previous studies indicated that the ratio of DNA to lipid is an important variable that determines the efficiency of transfection and the cellular toxicity [1, 13]. To evaluate the effect of varying the ratio of DNA to transfection reagent, the cells were transfected with a constant quantity of plasmid DNA in a complex with a variable amount of a given transfection reagent. One to three different DNA/reagent ratios were evaluated for each cell system. In each case, the optimum charge ratio for a given reagent was used for the comparison with nucleofection. The nucleofection buffer and program are critical parameters for nucleofection, so different programs and buffers were tested to obtain the optimal transfection efficiency.
Primary embryonic pig fibroblasts (P16) (obtained from Dr José Cibelli, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI) and embryonic rabbit ear fibroblasts (REF) (obtained from Dr Fuliang Du, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT)  were grown in Dulbecco's Modified Eagle's Medium (DMEM) supplemented with 15% or 10%, respectively, fetal calf serum (FCS, Hyclone), 2-mercaptoethanol (1.5%), and glutamine (2 mM). Sickle cell disease (SCD) transgenic mouse embryonic stem cells (MESCs) containing a YAC carrying 240 kB of the βS-globin locus (obtained from Dr YW Kan, University of California, San Francisco, CA) were grown on gelatin coated plates on a mitomycin C inactivated SNL mouse embryo fibroblast feeder layer expressing leukemia inhibitory factor (LIF) in DMEM containing and 15% FCS (Hyclone), 2 mM glutamine (Invitrogen), 10-4 M non-essential amino acids (Invitrogen), 104 M 2-mecaptoethanol (Sigma-Aldrich) . Immortalized human bronchial epithelial cells (16HBE14o- [16, 17] and CFBE41o- [18–20]) cells and the adenovirus 5 immortalized human embryo kidney cell line, HEK 293 , (American Type Tissue Culture Collection, Manassas, VA) were grown on tissue culture plastic coated with an extra-cellular matrix cocktail comprised of human fibronectin (FN) (BD laboratories, NJ), Vitrogen (V) (BD laboratories), and bovine serum albumin (BSA) (Biosource/Biofluids, Camarillo, CA) (FN/V/BSA) in Minimum Essential Medium (MEM) supplemented with 10% FCS, 1% (v/v) glutamine, 1% pen/strep . Primary pig and human tracheal epithelial (PTE and HTE, respectively) cells (obtained from Dr J H Widdicombe, University of California, Davis, CA and Dr W E Finkbeiner, University of California, San Francisco, CA) were grown in modified LHC8e medium (MLHC8e): LHC8 medium (Biosource/Biofluids) supplemented with 2 mM glutamine, 1 ml Stock 4 solution (Biosource/Biofluids), 2 μg/ml insulin (Biosource/Biofluids), 1 ml Trace Elements solution (Biosource/Biofluids), and epinephrine (0.5 μg/ml) (Biosource/Biofluids) . All cells were grown at 37°C in humidified air containing 5% CO2 and subcultured every 2-3 days by trypsinization.
SC1 lymphoblasts (American Type Tissue Culture Collection, Manassas, VA, ATCC#CRL-8756) were homozygous for the sickle cell allele) and LT1-1B1 human lymphoblasts with a G>C substitution mutation in exon 3 in HPRT1 gene (codon 51) . SC1 cells were grown in suspension culture in RPMI 1640 medium supplemented with 20% Fetal Calf Serum (ATCC) with routine media changes every 48 h. LT1-1B1 cells were also grown in RPMI 1640 medium but supplemented with 10% FBS (Sigma, St Louis, MO), 5 mM L-glutamine, 40 mM HEPES, and 10 mM 6-thioguanine (6TG) (Sigma, company info). Hematopoietic CD34+ cells were isolated from human fetal liver (obtained from Dr M Meunch, University of California, San Francisco, CA) and grown as described previously  in serum-free culture medium consisting of Iscove's modified Dulbecco's medium (IMDM) (Sigma Chemical, St. Louis, MO) supplemented with 7.5 10-5 α-thioglycerol (Sigma Chemical), 50 μg/ml gentamicin, 2% fraction-V ethanol-extracted BSA (Boehringer Mannheim Biochemicals, Indianapolis, Indiana, USA), 200 μg/ml human iron-saturated transferrin (Boehringer Mannheim Biochemicals), 10 μg/ml recombinant human insulin (Boehringer Mannheim Biochemicals), and 20 μg protein/ml human low density lipoprotein (Sigma Chemical), 10 U/ml erythropoietin (Amgen, Thousand Oaks, CA), and 50 ng/ml c-kit ligand (KL) (R&D Systems Inc., Minneapolis, MN). Cells were grown under humidified conditions in 5% CO2 with media changes every 48 h.
All cells were obtained with the appropriate IRB and IACUC approvals at the institutions where they were generated. The human samples were obtained in accordance with the Helsinki Declaration http://www.wma.net/en/30publications/10policies/b3/index.html from autopsy material with informed consent when samples had identifiable markers. When samples were anonymous, informed consent was not required for autopsy materials or discarded tissue. Human fetal livers were obtained from mid-gestation fetuses after maternal consent from elective abortions. Research with fetal tissue and human tracheal epithelial cells obtained from autopsy were performed with approval of the Committee of Human Research at the University of California, San Francisco under approvals H8858-18760-04/05 and H493-27303-04, respectively.
Cells and Optimal Nucleofection Conditions
Pig Fetal Fibroblasts
Primary Pig Tracheal Epithelial Cells
Basic epithelial cell
Immortalized Human Bronchial Epithelial cell Line (WT)
Immortalized Human CF Bronchial Epithelial Cell Line (ΔF508/ΔF508))
Primary Human Tracheal Epithelial Cells
Basic epithelial cell
Immortalized Human Lymphoblasts (HPRT mutant)
Immortalized Human Lymphoblasts (βS-globin mutant)
Primary Hematopoietic Stem/Progenitor Cells (CD34+ lin-)
Adenovirus immortalized human embryonic kidney cells
Rabbit Ear Fibroblasts
Transgenic mouse embryonic stem cells (βS-globin mutant)
Mouse ES cell
The MESCs were separated from the SNL feeder cells by short-term (30 min) plating of the trypsinized mixed cell population in Petri dishes not coated with gelatin. The SNL fibroblasts preferentially adhere and the MESCs are readily harvested for nucleofection.
Before transfection 3 - 5 × 105 cells were seeded into individual wells of 6 well plates. After a 24 h incubation in growth medium, the cells were exposed to the polyplexes or lipoplexes that each contained 2 μg pmaxGFP plasmid/well of cells. Each transfection was carried out in triplicate and repeated 2 to 3 times. Following transfection the cells were incubated at 37°C in humidified-air (5% CO2) for 2 h. The transfection medium was then removed and the cells were incubated for an additional 48 h in complete medium (2 ml per well).
Plasmid DNA and Lipofectamine 2000 (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA) were diluted in two independent 250 μl volumes of Opti-MEM reduced serum medium (Invitrogen) without serum and mixed gently. For Lipofectamine Plus transfections, the DNA was pre-incubated with 4 μl of Plus reagent and Opti-MEM to a final volume of 25 μl. After a 5 min incubation at room temperature, the DNA and the Lipofectamine 2000 in Opti-MEM were combined and incubated for an additional 20 min at room temperature to allow the DNA-Lipofectamine 2000 complexes to form. The DNA- Plus mix (25 μl) was added to an equal volume the Lipofectamine 2000 reagent mixed with Opti-MEM and incubated for an additional 30 min at room temperature. The DNA-Lipofectamine 2000 complexes were then added to each well containing cells and medium. The vol/wt ratios of Lipofectamine 2000/DNA were: 3/1, 5/1 and 7/1, and 1/1 for Lipofectamine Plus/DNA.
PEI (QBiogene, Morgan Irvine, CA) and plasmid DNA were each diluted with equal volumes of 150 mM NaCl. The DNA solution was then added to the PEI solution, and after a 20 min incubation at room temperature, 200 μl/well aliquots of the DNA-PEI complexes were added to cells grown in serum containing medium in individual wells. The charge ratios (+/-) of PEI nitrogen residues/DNA phosphates were: 3/1, 5/1 and 8/1
Effectene transfections were conducted according to the manufacturer's instructions (Qiagen, Valencia, CA). The vol/wt ratios of Effectene/DNA were 10/1 and 25/1.
Cells were harvested 48 h post-transfection, washed, and resuspended in PBS. In adherent cell cultures, only cells adhering to the culture dish before trypsinization were counted as viable. Cells in suspension were exposed to PBS containing 0.02% EGTA and 1 μg/ml propidium iodide to identify the nonviable cells through propidium iodide fluorescence. The cells were then sorted by flow cytometry, evaluated with the Cellquest software (BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA) to determine the proportion of fluorescent cells.
Where B = the # of adherent or total # of cells when grown in suspension, in the transfected sample at the time of harvest, C = # of nontransfected adherent or total # of cells when grown in suspension, present at the time of harvest, and T is toxicity.
This proportion of live cells present at the time of harvest was taken to be an indicator of relative cell cytotoxicity and consequently, the cell viability following transfection.
Primary airway epithelial cells play a crucial role in the study of airway disease and infection. The ability to efficiently transfer of genes into these cells is critical in evaluating the mechanisms underlying airway epithelial cell function and airway disease pathology. Because there was no optimized protocol available for nucleofection of primary human or pig tracheal epithelial cells, 3 different buffers were tested (EP-39, EP-42 and E-58 (Basic Epithelial Cell buffer)). Optimization of the human tracheal epithelial (HTE) cells involved pairing each buffer with 9 different programs. The optimal transfection efficiency was achieved using program T-20 and the Amaxa Basic Epithelial Cell buffer and resulted in 47% expression efficiency and 83% cytotoxicity (17% viability) (Figure 1, Table 1).
Nucleofection of primary pig tracheal epithelial (PTE) cells under the same conditions, i.e., using the same buffer and program, gave a transfection efficiency of 90%. The 5% cytotoxicity (95% viability) of the transfected PTE cells detected 48 h after transfection was considerably less than that observed with the HTE cells (Figure 1)
Immortalized bronchial epithelial cells [26–28] were studied, because they are routinely used as models of cystic fibrosis (CF) and airway disease. Normal, 16HBE14o- , and CF, CFBE41o- [17–20], cell lines were optimally transfected with buffer V and program O-17 (Table 1). The 16HBE14o- cells showed a 62% viability and 65% transfection efficiency, while transfection of the CFBE41o- cells gave 81% expression efficiency at 50% viability (Figure 1).
Hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells (HSPCs) are attractive targets for gene delivery and therapy because of their potential for self-renewal and multilineage differentiation [29, 30]. These properties make them ideally suited for ex vivo gene transfer that could result in a treatment for numerous inherited and/or hematologic disorders.
HSPCs isolated from fetal liver  were nucleofected using Amaxa CD34 buffer and program U-08 (Table 1). GFP was expressed in 55% of the HSPCs accompanied by a viability of 50%. Furthermore, the ability of the HSPCs to differentiate into red blood cells persisted after transfection when the cells were grown in differentiating medium (R Maurisse and DC Gruenert, unpublished data).
Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) transformed lymphocytes (lymphoblasts) were nucleofected with buffer T and program G-16 (Table 1). The transfection efficiency of two different lymphoblast lines (SC-1 and LT1-1B1) was 75% with an 80% viability (Figure 1).
Transgenic mouse embryonic stem cells (MESCs) that contain a YAC that carries 240-kb βS-globin gene family  were optimally transfected using the Amaxa MESC buffer with program A-24 (Table 1). The transfection efficiency and viability was 62% and 66%, respectively (Figure 1). The cells were not effectively transfected using chemical reagents due to high cytotoxicity and/or senescence following reagent exposure (H Emamekhoo and DC Gruenert, unpublished observations).
The HEK 293 (human embryonic kidney) cell lines was nucleofected with Amaxa buffer V and program X-01 (Table 1). The efficiency of transfection and the viability were 93% and 72%, respectively (Figure 1).
Only the optimal, i.e., in terms of transfection efficiency, reagent/DNA ratios were compared (Figure 2). The data presented compares the relative effectiveness of plasmid delivery into pig fetal fibroblast (P16) as well as primary human and pig tracheal epithelial cells (HTE and PTE, respectively) by chemical reagents and nucleofection.
P16 cells were transfected with 2 μg of pmaxGFP plasmid. The transfection efficiencies were 18% (Effectene 25/1), 28% (Lipofectamine 2000; 7/1), 20% (Lipofectamine Plus) and 32% (PEI; 3/1) (Figure 2-A). Transfection by nucleofection gave an efficiency of 85%.
PTE were transfected with 2 μg pmaxGFP plasmid in a complex with Effectene, Lipofectamine 2000, Lipofectamine Plus and PEI (Figure 2-B). The transfection efficiencies of the PTE cells were 5% (Effectene; 25/1), 30% (Lipofectamine 2000; 7/1), 21% (Lipofectamine Plus) and 10% (PEI; 3/1) transfection respectively at the ratio indicated (Figure 2). The nucleofection resulted in a transfection efficiency of 90% and cytotoxicity of 5%.
HTE cells were transfected with the four reagents indicated below and by nucleofection (Figure 2-C). The transfection efficiencies obtained were: 37% (Effectene; 25/1), 14% (Lipofectamine 2000; 7/1), 3% (Lipofectamine Plus; 1/1), and 8% (PEI; 3/1), respectively (Figure 2C). Nucleofection gave a transfection efficiency of 45%.
The transfection efficiency and viability with Lipofectamine 2000 was 98% and 67%, respectively. The transfection efficiency with Lipofectamine Plus was 82% with a viability of 80% (data not shown).
The delivery of genes into primary and immortalized cell lines is an underpinning of mammalian molecular biology and has become increasingly important in biomedical research and therapeutic development. Defining the parameters necessary for transfection optimization is, thus a critical element in further enhancing gene delivery efficacy in a wide range of cells. While there has been significant work done in the development of chemical and viral reagents for the delivery of recombinant DNA, only limited improvements have been made in physical delivery systems . The development of a novel electroporation system by AMAXA has shown considerable promise as a system for delivering DNA to a broad range of cell lines and cell systems that grow either as adherent monolayers or in suspension [7, 31–34]. A number of cell lines from human and animals that have been particularly important for characterization of airway diseases such as cystic fibrosis and asthma, for somatic cell nuclear transfer, for the study of hematopoietic diseases, and for mutation analysis were evaluated and compared for their ability to be efficaciously transfected with the nucleofection system. With the exception of HEK293 cells, when compared to chemical DNA delivery vehicles, nucleofection appears to be, in general, more effective and less toxic. The transfection efficiency and toxicity is equivalent following nucleofection or Lipofectamine transfection of HEK293 cells (Figure 1).
Transfection of two immortalized human airway epithelial cell lines, 16HBE14o- and CFB41o- and primary airway epithelial cells from pig and human (PTE and HTE, respectively) showed that nucleofection was more effective than the four chemical reagents tested with the exception of the HTE cells that were also effectively transfectable with Effectene. Primary human airway epithelial cells were difficult to transfect even by nucleofection (45%) when compared to the PTE (95%). While the reason for this difference is not certain, it is possible that cells at different passages or in different stages of differentiation will have varying responses to insult. Additional studies will need to be undertaken to determine whether the transfection efficiency and viability following nucleofection can be further enhanced.
The development of somatic cell nuclear transfer using fetal fibroblast as donor cells has played a central role in the cloning of animals such as the pig and the rabbit [14, 35–37]. Greater than 95% of the P16 cells expressed GFP following nucleofection while the rabbit ear fibroblasts (REF) appeared to be more recalcitrant to transfection and gave a GFP expression frequency in the range of 40%. This difference may be due to species-specific factors that affect the transport and/or of expression the plasmid DNA in the cell nucleus. In addition, differences in the age of the cultured cells, and cell density may also play a factor. These elements need to be considered when optimizing transfection conditions and should be addressed empirically.
Suspension cultures of hematopoietic origin have been notoriously difficult to transfect with chemical reagents and have had to rely on viral vector systems to facilitate DNA delivery . However, the studies here showed that nucleofection was able to transfect both primary human hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells as well as immortalized lymphoblasts giving levels GFP expression in the range of 60-80% with relatively low levels of cytotoxicity. Thus, nucleofection may be an effective means of ex vivo genetic modification of hematopoietic stem cells that have multilineage potential.
Embryonic stem (ES) cells have become increasingly more important due their potential for organ regeneration and for the development of models to study disease. Mouse ES cells (MESCs) have been notoriously difficult to transfect with chemical reagents, and have thus been relegated to transfection by electroporation. Standard electroporation protocols have resulted in high levels of cytotoxicity that have undermined the ability to transfer genes into the cells and the potential of the MESCs to produce viable embryos or differentiate in a lineage directed fashion. The nucleofection system has provided the opportunity to overcome some of these issues by enhancing transfection efficacy and MESC viability. As indicated by the studies presented here, MESCs can be routinely transfected at efficiencies of about 60% with a concurrent 60% viability. These observations have important implications for the transfection of human ES cells and for their genetic modification and directed differentiation in that nucleofection has the potential of producing genetically modified cells that can be phenotypically manipulated without losing their pluripotency.
This study demonstrates the nucleofection system is effective for a broad range of cell lines and cell types, resulting in high levels of transgene expression and low toxicity. Not only is it superior when compared to various commercially available chemical DNA delivery vehicles in terms of transfection efficacy and viability, it also has potential therapeutic applications in ex vivo gene delivery.
American Type Tissue Culture Collection
CF bronchial epithelial
Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium
enhanced green fluorescent protein
fetal calf serum
fibronectin/Vitrogen/bovine serum albumin
hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells
human bronchial epithelial
human embryo kidney
hypoxanthine phosphoribosyl transferase
human tracheal epithelial
Iscove's modified Dulbecco's medium
leukemia inhibitory factor
minimal essential medium
mouse ES cells
phosphate buffered saline
pig tracheal epithelial
rabbit embryo fibroblasts
sickle cell disease
yeast artificial chromosome
We would like to acknowledge Dr Jose Cibelli for the pig fetal fibroblasts, Dr Fuliang Du for the rabbit ear fibroblasts, Dr Jonathan Widdicombe for the primary pig and and Dr Walter Finkbeiner for the primary human tracheal epithelial cells, Dr Marcus Meunch for his assistance in obtaining the human hematopoietic stem/progenitor cells, and Dr YW Kan for the transgenic mouse ES cells. This work was supported by NIH grants DK66403, GM75111, and HL80814 as well as grants from the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation, Pennsylvania Cystic Fibrosis, Inc., and the California Pacific Medical Center Research Foundation. AA and HE received support from NIH Training Grant, DK007636.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.