Skip to main content

Table 2 Experimental design and results of the Box-Behnken Design

From: Tofu processing wastewater as a low-cost substrate for high activity nattokinase production using Bacillus subtilis

 

Factor 1

Factor 2

Factor 3

Factor 4

Enzyme activity (IU/mL)

Run

A: Glucose (g/L)

B: TPW (%)

C: MgSO4·7H2O (g/L)

D: CaCl2 (g/L)

Actual value

Predicted value

1

22.5

100

1

1

7472.70 ± 137.28

7549.40

2

22.5

75

0.5

0.1

6863.40 ± 84.29

6484.19

3

22.5

100

0.5

0.55

7719.21 ± 69.39

7763.18

4

35

75

1

1

4637.23 ± 32.82

5219.90

5

10

75

0.5

0.55

5608.72 ± 118.44

5867.68

6

22.5

75

1

0.55

7202.28 ± 72.56

7045.27

7

22.5

50

1

1

2552.45 ± 40.53

2729.88

8

22.5

75

0.5

1

6631.05 ± 31.61

6298.53

9

22.5

100

1.5

0.55

7563.01 ± 50.01

7541.37

10

22.5

75

1

0.55

7306.88 ± 48.21

7045.27

11

22.5

50

1.5

0.55

2685.39 ± 156.66

2746.88

12

35

75

1.5

0.55

4927.65 ± 94.96

4905.82

13

22.5

75

1.5

1

6627.17 ± 75.44

6663.81

14

22.5

75

1

0.55

7163.78 ± 46.64

7045.27

15

35

100

1

0.55

6522.90 ± 55.96

5870.37

16

22.5

75

1

0.55

6900.12 ± 49.35

7045.27

17

10

75

1

1

5680.77 ± 71.76

5139.86

18

10

75

1.5

0.55

5507.49 ± 66.73

5462.89

19

10

50

1

0.55

1505.96 ± 69.34

1815.91

20

22.5

50

0.5

0.55

2586.87 ± 60.69

2713.96

21

10

100

1

0.55

6337.79 ± 52.37

6831.60

22

22.5

75

1

0.55

6653.31 ± 42.06

7045.27

23

35

50

1

0.55

1878.74 ± 55.13

1042.35

24

35

75

0.5

0.55

4408.22 ± 78.25

4689.94

25

22.5

75

1.5

0.1

5940.07 ± 78.91

5930.00

26

10

75

1

0.1

6290.44 ± 87.9

5813.23

27

22.5

50

1

0.1

2193.04 ± 137.11

2353.47

28

22.5

100

1

0.1

7317.97 ± 126.32

7377.67

29

35

75

1

0.1

3352.02 ± 175.91

3998.39