A comparison between two brine shrimp assays to detect in vitrocytotoxicity in marine natural products
© Carballo et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2002
Received: 26 February 2002
Accepted: 23 September 2002
Published: 23 September 2002
The brine shrimp lethality assay is considered a useful tool for preliminary assessment of toxicity. It has also been suggested for screening pharmacological activities in plant extracts. However, we think that it is necessary to evaluate the suitability of the brine shrimp methods before they are used as a general bio-assay to test natural marine products for pharmacological activity.
Material and Methods
The bioactivity of the isopropanolic (2-PrOH) extracts of 14 species of marine invertebrates and 6 species of macroalgae was evaluated with the shrimp lethality assay (lethality assay), as well as with another assay based on the inhibition of hatching of the cyst (hatchability assay). The extracts were also assayed for cytotoxicity against two human cell lines, lung carcinoma A-549 and colon carcinoma HT-29, in order to assess the sensitivity of the shrimp assays to detect cytotoxic activity.
Two sponges (Hyatella sp, Dysidea sp.), two gorgonians (Pacifigorgia adamsii, Muricea sp.), one tunicate (Polyclinum laxum), and three echinoderms (Holothuria impatiens, Pseudoconus californica and Pharia pyramidata) showed a strong cytostatic (growth inhibition) and cytotoxic effect. The hatchability assay showed a strong activity in 4 of the species active against the two human cell lines tested (Hyatella sp, Dysidea sp., Pacifigorgia adamsii and Muricea sp.), and the lethality assay also showed a high lethality in 4 of them (Pacifigorgia adamsii, Muricea sp., Polyclinum laxum, and Pharia pyramidata). Each bioassay detected activity in 50% of the species that were considered active against the two human cell lines tested. However, the simultaneous use of both bioassays increased the percentage to 75%.
Our results seem consistent with the correlation previously established between cytotoxicity and brine shrimp lethality in plant extracts. We suggest using both bioassays simultaneously to test natural marine products for pharmacological activity.
The shrimp lethality assay was proposed by Michael et al. , and later developed by Vanhaecke et al. , and Sleet and Brendel . It is based on the ability to kill laboratory-cultured Artemia nauplii brine shrimp. The assay is considered a useful tool for preliminary assessment of toxicity , and it has been used for the detection of fungal toxins , plant extract toxicity , heavy metals , cyanobacteria toxins , pesticides , and cytotoxicity testing of dental materials .
On the other hand, although most researchers have made use of the hatched nauplii, other assays based on the inhibition of hatching of the cyst (encased embryos that are metabolically inactive) have also been used .
We think that it is necessary to evaluate the suitability of both methods before the brine shrimp method is used as a general bio-assay technique to test natural marine products for biological and pharmacological activity.
Our aim was to assess the bioactivity of organic extracts from 20 species of marine organisms (mainly invertebrates) with two Artemia brine shrimp assays, and then compare the results with those obtained for cytotoxic activity against two human cell lines: lung carcinoma A-549 and colon carcinoma HT-29.
For this purpose, we developed a method based on the percentage of hatching of the cyst which was incubated in a medium with different concentrations of organic extracts. Toxicity was measured by comparing the percentage of hatched nauplii to a control.
Our study is part of a program for screening a variety of biological activities in marine fauna in order to find new substances with potential pharmaceutical applications.
Results and discussion
Cytotoxicity assay against human lung carcinoma (A-549) and human colon carcinoma (HT-29)
Toxicity of the isopropanolic extracts against lung (A-549), colon carcinoma (HT-29), and brine shrimp assays
Brine shrimp bioassays
Only a few species were bioactive against the brine shrimp bioassays at 10 and 100 μg de extract per ml, and a low relationship between the brine shrimp bioassays and the cytotoxicity assays was found. However, most of the invertebrates presented toxicity in some of the bioassays at 1000 μg/ml in a way that was consistent with the citotoxicity results. The macroalgae was the group where least activity was detected. A strong hatch inhibition (hatchability assay) was present in the extracts of the sponges Hyatella sp. (51%), Mycale parishii (64%) and Dysidea sp. (50%), and in the extracts of the gorgonians Lophogorgia sp. (81%), Pacifigorgia adamsii (76%) and Muricea sp. (89%). After 12 h of exposure, the percentage of active species increased very slightly. After 24 h of exposure there were no significant changes in the activity of the extracts, although a few species such as Muricea sp. and Lophogorgia were more active at 48 h than at 24 h.
On the other hand, a high lethality was found in the extracts of the gorgonians Pacifigorgia adamsii (68%), Muricea sp. (83%), the tunicate Polyclinum laxum (96%) and the echinoderms Toxopneustes roseus (96%), Isostichopus fuscus (96%) and Pharia pyramidata (93%) (Table 1). In this case, activity increased significantly with up to 48 h of exposure.
With respect to the effect of the time of exposure, in the hatchability test the highest percentage of toxicity was detected at 12 h or 24 h of exposure, and significant changes in toxicity were not detected in subsequent times of exposure. The very low hatching rate detected after the 12 h treatment was probably due to an alteration in the development of Artemia embryos. It has been shown that Artemia is highly vulnerable to toxins at the early developmental stages [12, 13]. In contrast, in the brine shrimp lethality test, maximum sensibility was reached after 48 h of exposure (the oldest age class tested by us) . At this stage in their life cycle the nauplii have reached their second and third instar and exhibit their greatest sensitivity to test compounds .
The hatchability test detected toxicity in a number of species similar to the lethality test, but seemed less sensitive to detect toxicity of macroalgae extracts. In general, the groups with the highest percentage of toxic species, and with the most toxic extracts, were the invertebrates. Some species such as the echinoderms, the sponges Mycale parishii, Dysidea, sp, and the gorgonians Muricea sp. etc, significantly lowered hatching in the hatchability test, interfering with normal development of the nauplii. The echinoderms Toxopneustes roseus, Isostichopus fuscus, etc. presented a high lethality (almost 100%).
The high incidence of toxicity in sponges and echinoderms seems to be an effective defense mechanism against many predation fishes, which increases closer to the tropics (almost 100% of all species tested) .
For the past 30 years, the Artemia nauplii have been used to detect general toxicity , in teratology screens [3, 13, 18, 19] and in ecotoxicology [12, 17]. From a pharmacological point of view, a good relationship has been found with the brine shrimp lethality test to detect antitumoral compounds in terrestrial plant extracts [4, 20, 21].
These two bioassays show that standard tests employing organisms such as brine shrimp are useful in identifying metabolites with a high potential for activity against marine organisms. Our results show that the shrimp hatchability test together with the lethality test could be an easy bioassay to screen marine natural products.
Collection and preparation of extracts
4 species of sponges, 3 gorgonians, 6 echinoderms, 1 tunicate, and 6 macroalgae (Table 1) were collected by snorkeling and scuba diving from low tide to a depth of 20 m along the Mexican Pacific coast. The specimens of each species were freeze-dried and ground together. The lyophilized material (2–5 g) was extracted three times with 2-PrOH (1/20) w/v. The extracts were evaporated under reduced pressure and dissolved in acetone/methanol (1:1) to prepare the stock solution.
Preparation of the bioassays
The tests were conducted in multiwell plates in filtered (0.45 μm pore diameter) and sterilized seawater (final volume 5 ml). Each of the extracts for each species was tested at 1000, 100 and 10 μg of extract per ml. The concentrations were obtained by transferring the corresponding volume from the stock solution to different wells for evaporation . After evaporation, 5 ml of seawater were added to each well with gentle shaking to ensure that the compounds diffused adequately in the aqueous solution. Four replicates were used for each treatment and control. The control was performed by adding the solvent used to dissolve the extracts in the assays, and it was allowed to evaporate. Before the assays, the average time of appearance of the first free nauplii and the subsequent developmental stages was calculated. The first cysts hatched approximately after 12 h of incubation (average time); the maximum percentage of instar II (55.33%) appeared 12 h later (24 h after the start of incubation). All the tests were performed in a temperature-controlled room at 28°C, under a continuous light regime. The extracts were subjected to the following tests:
Brine shrimp hatchability test
The brine shrimp hatchability test is based on Migliore et al. . They calculated the hatch, harvesting the free nauplii from 1 g of cysts on a Millipore 45 μm filter, weighed and placed in a desiccator at 60 C for 24 h to obtain the dry weight. In our case, the percentages of hatchability were calculated by comparing the number of free nauplii in each treatment with the number of free nauplii in the control and the whole procedure was standardized (see below).
Following the procedure in Amat , 0.5 g of dried cysts were separated from their shells using the commercial brine shrimp hatchers solution. After that, the cysts were hatched in seawater (1 g cyst per liter) at 28°C, under conditions of continuous illumination and strong aeration. After 2 h aliquots measuring 250 μl were placed in each well where the extracts had previously been deposited, and they were incubated at the same conditions of temperature and illumination under gentle shaking. After 12, 24 and 48 h of exposure the free nauplii were counted under a stereoscopic microscope. The percentages of hatchability were calculated by comparing the number of free nauplii in each treatment with the number of free nauplii in the control. Later the percentage of hatch inhibition (%HI) was calculated as: % HI = % hatchability in the control - % hatchability in each treatment.
Brine shrimp lethality test
Dried cysts were performed as indicated above, and incubated (1 g cyst per liter) in a hatcher at 28–30°C with strong aeration, under a continuous light regime. Approximately 12 h after hatching the phototropic nauplii were collected with a pipette from the lighted side and concentrated in a small vial. Ten brine shrimp were transferred to each well using adequate pipettes. Each test consisted of exposing groups of 10 Artemia aged 12 h to various concentrations of the toxic compound. The toxicity was determined after 12 h (mainly nauplii in instar I/II), 24 h (nauplii in instar II/III) and 48 h (mainly nauplii in instar III/IV) of exposure.
The numbers of survivors were counted and percentage of deaths were calculated. Larvae were considered dead if they did not exhibit any internal or external movement during several seconds of observation.
The larvae did not receive food. To ensure that the mortality observed in the bioassay could be attributed to bioactive compounds and not to starvation; we compared the dead larvae in each treatment to the dead larvae in the control. In any case, hatched brine shrimp nauplii can survive for up to 48 h without food  because they still feed on their yolk-sac . However, in cases where control deaths were detected, the percentage of mortality (% M) was calculated as: % M = percentage of survival in the control - percentage of survival in the treatment.
Bioassays for cytotoxicity
The cytotoxicity of the extracts was assessed employing two human cell lines: lung carcinoma (A-549), and colon carcinoma (HT-29). A colorimetric type of assay using a sulforhodamine B (SRB) reaction was adapted for a quantitative measurement of cell growth and viability, following the technique described by Skehan et al. . Cells were seeded in 96-well microtiter plates, at 5 × 103 cells per well in aliquots of 190 μl, and they were allowed to attach to the plate surface by growing in a drug free medium for 18 hours. Afterward, samples were added in aliquots of 10 μl (dissolved in DMSO/H2O 1:9). After 48 hours of exposure, the cytotoxicity was measured by the SRB methodology: cells were fixed by adding 50 μl of cold 50% (w/v) trichloroacetic acid (TCA), and incubating for 60 minutes at 4°C. Plates were washed with deionized water and dried. One hundred μl of SRB solution (0.4% w/v in 1% acetic acid) was added to each microtiter well, and incubated for 10 minutes at room temperature. Unbound SRB was removed by washing with 1% acetic acid. Plates were air dried and bound stain was dissolved with Tris buffer. Optical densities were read on an automated spectrophotometric plate reader at a single wavelength of 490 nm. Data analysis was generated automatically by LIMS implementation at PharmaMar and some parameters for cellular responses were calculated. The activity of the isopropanolic extracts was given in % GI (growth inhibition) for each concentration tested (50, 17 and 5 μg per ml). Values could be as follows:
negative GI = no growth inhibition (NOT ACTIVE)
< 50% GI = week growth inhibition (NOT ACTIVE)
50 to 100% GI = moderate to high growth inhibition (ACTIVE, growth inhibition effect)
100% GI = Total growth inhibition (ACTIVE, cytostatic effect)
>100% GI = Cell killing (ACTIVE, cytotoxic effect).
We appreciate the economic support given by CONACYT to finance the research projects entitled "Búsqueda y evaluación de recursos marinos con propiedades farmacológicas del Mar de Cortés" Proyecto SIMAC: 980106071, and "Biodiversidad, distribución y sistemática de ascidias con potencialidad farmacológica" Proyecto CONACYT. The authors also wish to express their gratitude to Cristina Vega Juarez and Veronica Maldonado for their help in performing the bioassays, to Ms Clara Ramirez Jauregui for generous help with the literature, to German Ramirez Reséndiz and Carlos Suarez for their computer assistance; all of them part of the staff of the ICML-UNAM (Mazatlán unit). We are grateful for a grant given by the CECyT (Consejo Estatal de Ciencia y Tecnología del Gobierno de Sinaloa).
- Michael AS, Thompson CG, Abramovitz M: Artemia salina as a test organism for a bioassay. Science. 1956, 123: 464-View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Vanhaecke P, Persoone G, Claus C, Sorgeloos P: Proposal for a short-term toxicity test with Artemia nauplii. Ecotoxicol Env Safety. 1981, 5: 382-387.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sleet RB, Brendel K: Improved methods for harvesting and counting synchronous populations of Artemia nauplii for use in developmental toxicology. Ecotoxicol Env Safety. 1983, 7: 435-446.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Solís PN, Wright CW, Anderson MM, Gupta MP, Phillipson JD: A microwell cytotoxicity assay using Artemia salina. Plant Med. 1993, 59: 250-252.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Harwig J, Scott P: Brine shrimp (Artemia salina L.) larvae as a screening system for fungal toxins. Appl Microbiol. 1971, 21: 1011-1016.Google Scholar
- McLauglin JL, Chang CJ, Smith DL: Bench top" bioassay for the discovery of bioactive natural products: an update. In: Studies in Natural Products Chemistry. Edited by: AU Rahman. 1991, Elsevier, 383-409.Google Scholar
- Martínez M, Del ramo J, Torreblanca A, Díaz-Mayans J: Effect of cadmium exposure on zinc levels in the brine shrimp Artemia partenogenética. Aquaculture. 1998, 172: 315-325. 10.1016/S0044-8486(98)00431-1.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jaki B, Orjala J, Bürji HR, Sticher O: Biological screening of cyanobacteria for antimicrobial and molluscicidal activity, brine shrimp lethality, and cytotoxicity. Pharm Biol. 1999, 37: 138-143. 10.1076/phbi.18.104.22.16892.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Barahona MV, Sánchez-Fortún S: Toxicity of carbamates to the brine shrimp Artemia salina and the effect of atropine, BW284c51, iso-OMPA and 2-PAM on carbaryl toxicity. Env Pollut. 1999, 104: 469-476. 10.1016/S0269-7491(98)00152-3.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Pelka M, Danzl C, Distler W, Petschelt A: A new screening test toxicity testing of dental materials. J Dent. 2000, 28: 341-345. 10.1016/S0300-5712(00)00007-5.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Migliore L, Civitareale C, Brambilla G, Di delupis GD: Toxicity of several important agricultural antibiotics to Artemia. Wat Res. 1997, 31: 1801-1806. 10.1016/S0043-1354(96)00412-5.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sorgeloos P, Remiche-Van Der Wielen C, Persoone G: The use of Artemia nauplii for toxicity tests. A critical analysis. Ecotoxicol Env Safety. 1978, 2: 249-255.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sleet RB, Brendel K: Homogeneous populations of Artemia nauplii and their potential use for in vitro testing in developmental toxicology. Teratog Carcinog Mutagen. 1985, 5: 41-54.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sánchez-Fortún S, Sanz S, Barahona MV: Acute toxicity of several organophosphorous insecticides and protection by cholinergic antagonist and 2-PAM on Artemia salina larvae. Arch Environ Contam Toxicol. 1996, 31: 391-398. 10.1007/s002449900123.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Lewis GE: Testing the toxicity of extracts of Southern African plants using brine shrimp (Artemia salina). S Afr J Sci. 1995, 91: 382-Google Scholar
- Bakus GJ, Green G: Toxicity in sponges and holothurians: A geographical pattern. Science. 1974, 185: 951-952.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Persoone G, Wells PG: Artemia in aquatic toxicology: a review. In: Artemia Research and its Applications. Morphology, Genetics, Strain characterization Toxicology. Edited by: Sorgeloos P. 1987, Belgium, Universita Press, 259-275.Google Scholar
- Acey RA, Tomlison DW: Artemia salina as a model system for assessing the effects of xenobiotics on embryonic development. FASEB J. 1988, 2 (6): 8463-Google Scholar
- Kersetter HW, Schaffer DJ: Brine shrimp (Artemia salina) nauplii as a teratogen test system. Ecotoxicol Env Safety. 1983, 7: 435-446.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Meyer BN, Ferrigni NR, Putnam JE, Jacobsen LB, Nichols DE, McLaughlin JL: Brine Shrimp: A convenient general bioassay for active plant constituents. Plant med. 1982, 45: 31-34.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mackeen MM, Ali AM, Lajis NH, Kawazu K, Hassan Z, Amran M, Habsah M, Mooi LY, Mohamed SM: Antimicrobial, antioxidant, antitumour-promoting and cytotoxic activities of different plant part extracts of Garcinia atroviridis Griff. Ex T. Anders. J Ethnopharmacol. 2000, 72: 395-402. 10.1016/S0378-8741(00)00245-2.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Amat F: Utilización de Artemia en acuicultura. Informes técnicos del Instituto de Investigaciones Pesqueras. 1985, 128-129.Google Scholar
- Skehan PA, Storeng R, Monks A, McMahon J, Vistica D, Warren JT, Bokesch H, Kenney S, Boyd MR: New colorimetric cytotoxicity assay for anticancer drug screening. J Nat Can Inst. 1990, 82: 1107-1112.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article: verbatim copying and redistribution of this article are permitted in all media for any purpose, provided this notice is preserved along with the article's original URL.